Return a 404 if no valid thumbnail is found. (#9163)

If no thumbnail of the requested type exists, return a 404 instead
of erroring. This doesn't quite match the spec (which does not define
what happens if no thumbnail can be found), but is consistent with
what Synapse already does.

changelog.d/9163.bugfix

+Fix a long-standing bug where Synapse would return a 500 error when a thumbnail did not exist (and auto-generation of thumbnails was not enabled).

synapse/rest/media/v1/_base.py

@@ -300,6 +300,7 @@ class FileInfo:
         thumbnail_height (int)
         thumbnail_method (str)
         thumbnail_type (str): Content type of thumbnail, e.g. image/png
+        thumbnail_length (int): The size of the media file, in bytes.
     """
 
     def __init__(
@@ -312,6 +313,7 @@ class FileInfo:
         thumbnail_height=None,
         thumbnail_method=None,
         thumbnail_type=None,
+        thumbnail_length=None,
     ):
         self.server_name = server_name
         self.file_id = file_id
@@ -321,6 +323,7 @@ class FileInfo:
         self.thumbnail_height = thumbnail_height
         self.thumbnail_method = thumbnail_method
         self.thumbnail_type = thumbnail_type
+        self.thumbnail_length = thumbnail_length
 
 
 def get_filename_from_headers(headers: Dict[bytes, List[bytes]]) -> Optional[str]:

synapse/rest/media/v1/thumbnail_resource.py

@@ -16,7 +16,7 @@
 
 
 import logging
-from typing import TYPE_CHECKING
+from typing import TYPE_CHECKING, Any, Dict, List, Optional
 
 from twisted.web.http import Request
 
@@ -106,31 +106,17 @@ class ThumbnailResource(DirectServeJsonResource):
             return
 
         thumbnail_infos = await self.store.get_local_media_thumbnails(media_id)
-
-        if thumbnail_infos:
-            thumbnail_info = self._select_thumbnail(
-                width, height, method, m_type, thumbnail_infos
-            )
-
-            file_info = FileInfo(
-                server_name=None,
-                file_id=media_id,
-                url_cache=media_info["url_cache"],
-                thumbnail=True,
-                thumbnail_width=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_width"],
-                thumbnail_height=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_height"],
-                thumbnail_type=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_type"],
-                thumbnail_method=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_method"],
-            )
-
-            t_type = file_info.thumbnail_type
-            t_length = thumbnail_info["thumbnail_length"]
-
-            responder = await self.media_storage.fetch_media(file_info)
-            await respond_with_responder(request, responder, t_type, t_length)
-        else:
-            logger.info("Couldn't find any generated thumbnails")
-            respond_404(request)
+        await self._select_and_respond_with_thumbnail(
+            request,
+            width,
+            height,
+            method,
+            m_type,
+            thumbnail_infos,
+            media_id,
+            url_cache=media_info["url_cache"],
+            server_name=None,
+        )
 
     async def _select_or_generate_local_thumbnail(
         self,
@@ -276,26 +262,64 @@ class ThumbnailResource(DirectServeJsonResource):
         thumbnail_infos = await self.store.get_remote_media_thumbnails(
             server_name, media_id
         )
+        await self._select_and_respond_with_thumbnail(
+            request,
+            width,
+            height,
+            method,
+            m_type,
+            thumbnail_infos,
+            media_info["filesystem_id"],
+            url_cache=None,
+            server_name=server_name,
+        )
 
+    async def _select_and_respond_with_thumbnail(
+        self,
+        request: Request,
+        desired_width: int,
+        desired_height: int,
+        desired_method: str,
+        desired_type: str,
+        thumbnail_infos: List[Dict[str, Any]],
+        file_id: str,
+        url_cache: Optional[str] = None,
+        server_name: Optional[str] = None,
+    ) -> None:
+        """
+        Respond to a request with an appropriate thumbnail from the previously generated thumbnails.
+
+        Args:
+            request: The incoming request.
+            desired_width: The desired width, the returned thumbnail may be larger than this.
+            desired_height: The desired height, the returned thumbnail may be larger than this.
+            desired_method: The desired method used to generate the thumbnail.
+            desired_type: The desired content-type of the thumbnail.
+            thumbnail_infos: A list of dictionaries of candidate thumbnails.
+            file_id: The ID of the media that a thumbnail is being requested for.
+            url_cache: The URL cache value.
+            server_name: The server name, if this is a remote thumbnail.
+        """
         if thumbnail_infos:
-            thumbnail_info = self._select_thumbnail(
-                width, height, method, m_type, thumbnail_infos
+            file_info = self._select_thumbnail(
+                desired_width,
+                desired_height,
+                desired_method,
+                desired_type,
+                thumbnail_infos,
+                file_id,
+                url_cache,
+                server_name,
             )
-            file_info = FileInfo(
-                server_name=server_name,
-                file_id=media_info["filesystem_id"],
-                thumbnail=True,
-                thumbnail_width=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_width"],
-                thumbnail_height=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_height"],
-                thumbnail_type=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_type"],
-                thumbnail_method=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_method"],
-            )
-
-            t_type = file_info.thumbnail_type
-            t_length = thumbnail_info["thumbnail_length"]
+            if not file_info:
+                logger.info("Couldn't find a thumbnail matching the desired inputs")
+                respond_404(request)
+                return
 
             responder = await self.media_storage.fetch_media(file_info)
-            await respond_with_responder(request, responder, t_type, t_length)
+            await respond_with_responder(
+                request, responder, file_info.thumbnail_type, file_info.thumbnail_length
+            )
         else:
             logger.info("Failed to find any generated thumbnails")
             respond_404(request)
@@ -306,67 +330,117 @@ class ThumbnailResource(DirectServeJsonResource):
         desired_height: int,
         desired_method: str,
         desired_type: str,
-        thumbnail_infos,
-    ) -> dict:
+        thumbnail_infos: List[Dict[str, Any]],
+        file_id: str,
+        url_cache: Optional[str],
+        server_name: Optional[str],
+    ) -> Optional[FileInfo]:
+        """
+        Choose an appropriate thumbnail from the previously generated thumbnails.
+
+        Args:
+            desired_width: The desired width, the returned thumbnail may be larger than this.
+            desired_height: The desired height, the returned thumbnail may be larger than this.
+            desired_method: The desired method used to generate the thumbnail.
+            desired_type: The desired content-type of the thumbnail.
+            thumbnail_infos: A list of dictionaries of candidate thumbnails.
+            file_id: The ID of the media that a thumbnail is being requested for.
+            url_cache: The URL cache value.
+            server_name: The server name, if this is a remote thumbnail.
+
+        Returns:
+             The thumbnail which best matches the desired parameters.
+        """
+        desired_method = desired_method.lower()
+
+        # The chosen thumbnail.
+        thumbnail_info = None
+
         d_w = desired_width
         d_h = desired_height
 
-        if desired_method.lower() == "crop":
+        if desired_method == "crop":
+            # Thumbnails that match equal or larger sizes of desired width/height.
             crop_info_list = []
+            # Other thumbnails.
             crop_info_list2 = []
             for info in thumbnail_infos:
+                # Skip thumbnails generated with different methods.
+                if info["thumbnail_method"] != "crop":
+                    continue
+
                 t_w = info["thumbnail_width"]
                 t_h = info["thumbnail_height"]
-                t_method = info["thumbnail_method"]
-                if t_method == "crop":
-                    aspect_quality = abs(d_w * t_h - d_h * t_w)
-                    min_quality = 0 if d_w <= t_w and d_h <= t_h else 1
-                    size_quality = abs((d_w - t_w) * (d_h - t_h))
-                    type_quality = desired_type != info["thumbnail_type"]
-                    length_quality = info["thumbnail_length"]
-                    if t_w >= d_w or t_h >= d_h:
-                        crop_info_list.append(
-                            (
-                                aspect_quality,
-                                min_quality,
-                                size_quality,
-                                type_quality,
-                                length_quality,
-                                info,
-                            )
+                aspect_quality = abs(d_w * t_h - d_h * t_w)
+                min_quality = 0 if d_w <= t_w and d_h <= t_h else 1
+                size_quality = abs((d_w - t_w) * (d_h - t_h))
+                type_quality = desired_type != info["thumbnail_type"]
+                length_quality = info["thumbnail_length"]
+                if t_w >= d_w or t_h >= d_h:
+                    crop_info_list.append(
+                        (
+                            aspect_quality,
+                            min_quality,
+                            size_quality,
+                            type_quality,
+                            length_quality,
+                            info,
                         )
-                    else:
-                        crop_info_list2.append(
-                            (
-                                aspect_quality,
-                                min_quality,
-                                size_quality,
-                                type_quality,
-                                length_quality,
-                                info,
-                            )
+                    )
+                else:
+                    crop_info_list2.append(
+                        (
+                            aspect_quality,
+                            min_quality,
+                            size_quality,
+                            type_quality,
+                            length_quality,
+                            info,
                         )
+                    )
             if crop_info_list:
-                return min(crop_info_list)[-1]
-            else:
-                return min(crop_info_list2)[-1]
-        else:
+                thumbnail_info = min(crop_info_list)[-1]
+            elif crop_info_list2:
+                thumbnail_info = min(crop_info_list2)[-1]
+        elif desired_method == "scale":
+            # Thumbnails that match equal or larger sizes of desired width/height.
             info_list = []
+            # Other thumbnails.
             info_list2 = []
+
             for info in thumbnail_infos:
+                # Skip thumbnails generated with different methods.
+                if info["thumbnail_method"] != "scale":
+                    continue
+
                 t_w = info["thumbnail_width"]
                 t_h = info["thumbnail_height"]
-                t_method = info["thumbnail_method"]
                 size_quality = abs((d_w - t_w) * (d_h - t_h))
                 type_quality = desired_type != info["thumbnail_type"]
                 length_quality = info["thumbnail_length"]
-                if t_method == "scale" and (t_w >= d_w or t_h >= d_h):
+                if t_w >= d_w or t_h >= d_h:
                     info_list.append((size_quality, type_quality, length_quality, info))
-                elif t_method == "scale":
+                else:
                     info_list2.append(
                         (size_quality, type_quality, length_quality, info)
                     )
             if info_list:
-                return min(info_list)[-1]
-            else:
-                return min(info_list2)[-1]
+                thumbnail_info = min(info_list)[-1]
+            elif info_list2:
+                thumbnail_info = min(info_list2)[-1]
+
+        if thumbnail_info:
+            return FileInfo(
+                file_id=file_id,
+                url_cache=url_cache,
+                server_name=server_name,
+                thumbnail=True,
+                thumbnail_width=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_width"],
+                thumbnail_height=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_height"],
+                thumbnail_type=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_type"],
+                thumbnail_method=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_method"],
+                thumbnail_length=thumbnail_info["thumbnail_length"],
+            )
+
+        # No matching thumbnail was found.
+        return None

tests/rest/media/v1/test_media_storage.py

@@ -202,7 +202,6 @@ class MediaRepoTests(unittest.HomeserverTestCase):
 
         config = self.default_config()
         config["media_store_path"] = self.media_store_path
-        config["thumbnail_requirements"] = {}
         config["max_image_pixels"] = 2000000
 
         provider_config = {
@@ -313,15 +312,39 @@ class MediaRepoTests(unittest.HomeserverTestCase):
         self.assertEqual(headers.getRawHeaders(b"Content-Disposition"), None)
 
     def test_thumbnail_crop(self):
+        """Test that a cropped remote thumbnail is available."""
         self._test_thumbnail(
             "crop", self.test_image.expected_cropped, self.test_image.expected_found
         )
 
     def test_thumbnail_scale(self):
+        """Test that a scaled remote thumbnail is available."""
         self._test_thumbnail(
             "scale", self.test_image.expected_scaled, self.test_image.expected_found
         )
 
+    def test_invalid_type(self):
+        """An invalid thumbnail type is never available."""
+        self._test_thumbnail("invalid", None, False)
+
+    @unittest.override_config(
+        {"thumbnail_sizes": [{"width": 32, "height": 32, "method": "scale"}]}
+    )
+    def test_no_thumbnail_crop(self):
+        """
+        Override the config to generate only scaled thumbnails, but request a cropped one.
+        """
+        self._test_thumbnail("crop", None, False)
+
+    @unittest.override_config(
+        {"thumbnail_sizes": [{"width": 32, "height": 32, "method": "crop"}]}
+    )
+    def test_no_thumbnail_scale(self):
+        """
+        Override the config to generate only cropped thumbnails, but request a scaled one.
+        """
+        self._test_thumbnail("scale", None, False)
+
     def _test_thumbnail(self, method, expected_body, expected_found):
         params = "?width=32&height=32&method=" + method
         channel = make_request(